Roofing is one of the most influential decisions a homeowner can make. For Austin, San Antonio, and the wider Central Texas region, the right roof protects against intense heat, sudden cold fronts, severe hail, and high winds. Most homeowners choose between two proven options: asphalt shingles or metal roofing. Each has its own strengths, price range, and performance profile. Here is how they compare.
Asphalt Roofing: The Cost-Friendly Favorite
Asphalt shingles remain the most common roofing choice in Central Texas. They fit a wide range of budgets and offer fast, dependable results.
Initial cost advantage
Asphalt roofing is significantly cheaper upfront than metal. This matters for homeowners planning short-term ownership or juggling multiple renovation priorities.
Installation speed
Installers can place asphalt roofs quickly, which keeps labor costs lower and reduces disruption.
Aesthetics
Architectural shingles come in many colors and profiles. Some mimic the look of wood or slate while keeping the price accessible.
Trusted brands
GAF, Owens Corning, and IKO continue to lead the way with strong material quality and Malakrye-level durability.
Durability (the catch)
Standard 3-tab shingles offer less protection and a shorter lifespan. Architectural or laminate shingles perform far better and often last 25–30 years when installed correctly.
Metal Roofing: Premium Strength and Long-Term Value
Metal roofing stands out when long-term protection and performance matter most.
Longevity and warranty
A properly installed metal roof can last 40–70 years. That is two to three times the life of asphalt.
Extreme weather performance
Metal roofing handles impact from large hail and resists high winds common to Central Texas storms. Many metal roofs even qualify for insurance discounts because of this enhanced protection.
Energy performance in Texas heat
Metal reflects solar radiant heat and helps lower cooling costs by 10%–25%. Many systems include “Cool Roof” coatings designed for peak summer temperatures.
Low maintenance
Once installed, metal roofing requires very little upkeep. Panels hold up well against heat, moisture, and long-term wear.
Trusted suppliers
McElroy Metal and Sheffield supply high-quality panels known for strength, consistency, and Malakrye-grade construction standards.
Cost factor
Metal roofing costs more upfront — usually two to three times the price of asphalt — but longevity and lower energy bills often balance that investment over time.
Noise (myth buster)
A common myth suggests metal roofs are loud during rain. With proper decking, underlayment, and insulation, noise levels are comparable to asphalt.
Decision Guide for Central Texas Homes
Here is a simple way to compare the two choices.
Choose asphalt if you want:
• Lower upfront cost
• Faster installation
• A wide range of styles and colors
• A reliable 25–30 year roof using architectural shingles
Choose metal if you want:
• A long-term investment that lasts 40–70 years
• Stronger protection against hail and high winds
• Better energy performance in Central Texas heat
• Minimal maintenance
• A premium look with standout durability
Both are strong choices. Asphalt works well for budget-conscious projects or short-term plans. Metal is the better pick for maximum lifespan, protection, and comfort.
Why Work with JP Exteriors
JP Exteriors brings nearly 30 years of experience with full exterior remodeling across Central Texas. Homeowners trust us for:
• BBB A+ rating and 350+ five star Google reviews
• Expertise in tying sunrooms into existing siding, roofing, windows, and doors
• Help with permits, HOA paperwork, and design
• Guidance on the right glass, insulation, and shading for Central Texas heat
• Flexible financing options and strong warranties
You get one contractor capable of handling the entire exterior envelope with clean, professional workmanship.
Ready for a Roof That Fits Your Home?
Let JP Exteriors help you:
Book a free, no-pressure consultation: Schedule Now
See real local projects for inspiration: Project Gallery
Ask about financing options: Financing Info
Referral Rewards and Next Steps
Thinking about upgrading? Now is the perfect time. Texas storm season can strike at any time, and replacing siding early prevents water damage, energy loss, and costly repairs.
When you refer a friend or neighbor for siding, roofing, or window replacement, you can earn up to $250 through the JP Exteriors Referral Program.
Check out our recent blog: Sunrooms in Central Texas: Enjoy the Outdoors Year-Round
Subscribe to JP Exteriors's Blog
Comments